awesome window manager vs i3

02/12/2020
awesome window manager vs i3

Very Unix philosophy friendly. Sorry OP if I'm barging in. Haven't found a way to do that in i3. Deepin. I still like to have the windows titles still visible. (Yes, it's annoying that it's not h/j/k/l, i rebound them..). Yes, because you can configure the tiles to have very thin or no borders. For example, system administrators can open several terminals to monitor or work on different remote systems simultaneously; and developers can use their favorite IDE or editor and a few terminals to test their programs. awesome is a highly configurable, next generation framework window manager for X. I can Mod+Right Click drag windows to different locations and monitors. There are many useful cases for this. Though there is still some work to be done in this area. A colleague of mine suggested that I should try tiling window managers, and proceeded to produce a list of them, including i3, awesome, wmii and xmonad. tagged ubuntu, i3. It's extremely fast, small, dynamic and heavily extensible using the Lua programming language. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I use i3 standalone because it's fast and lightweight. As an avid i3 user I still recommend you check your options, as this is the proper way to do it. You’ll also need to inst… Since you don't need to worry about window positioning, i3 generally makes better use of your screen real estate. I used to use "ion" a long time ago (2003 ish), and awesome comes close to how I remember it, although there's still some things I liked about Ion that I haven't seen reproduced in any of the current tiling WMs. He is currently interested in hacking stuff using the Go Programming... 6 open source tools for staying organized, Free online course: RHEL Technical Overview. How would you compare i3 to awesome, awesome to i3, etc.? awesome is a free and open-source next-generation tiling manager for X built to be fast … I love i3..... Gnome, kde, plasma, xfce, mate cinnamon were my desktops before i3. On my desktop, I feel that the way the 9 tags are split between all of your monitors is a bit awkward to live with 24/7. Screen shots: i3 in MobaXTerm i3 behind Windows. With xfce4, have you tried looking at the settings under "window manager"? If you end up not liking i3, I'd give awesome a try. Finally, there is another, special type of workspace in i3: the scratchpad. Stacking window managers behave analogously to pieces of paper on a physical desktop, they can be stacked on top of one another, with the one at the top of the stack being the one with which the user sees and interacts. It is primarily targeted at power users, developers and any people dealing with every day computing tasks and who want to have fine-grained control on their graphical environment. If you use the terminal frequently, having a good window manager is essential to your well being. Just what I need. Another really major difference between i3 and awesome is the way they handle multi-monitor setups. Then I found i3, an amazing piece of software that changed my life. Yes. I also looked at this question, which points to installing lxappearance for this issue in Awesome Window Manager. (That is, the ability to have windows from several different tabs/workspaces showing at the same time). Budgie; The main Budgie article. Press +num to switch to workspace num. XMonad is ideal for you if you want totally extensible in Haskell and you will not be limited … Awesome. One goal of the project is to keep dwm minimal and small. awesome tries to complete these tools with what we miss: an extensible, highly configurable window manager. You need to learn a few basic shortcuts to get around at the beginning, but they'll soon feel natural and you'll start using them without thinking. Indeed, the only way to change dwm default configuration is to In Awesome, I love just cycling thought all windows in a clockwise fashion using 'j' and 'k', vs. explicitly going up/down left/right. i3 also allows for things like moving a tag from one screen to the next. The extra room can make a big difference on a small screen. Dynamic window managers are window managers that can dynam… Enter i3. You will not find many distros using the i3 tiling window manager. windows; linux; i3; windows; linux; i3; Career 2.0 - Go Training, Videos, Speaking. 1. For example, the entire code base never exceeded 2000 lines of code. Window re-sizing is more intuitive in Awesome, for me anyway. Thankfully, i3 comes with both. I really like it, and I'll probably continue using it even if I don't have the nice GTK themes, but obviously it would be nicer to Flexible. v-split, h-split. For me, they look like the same thing, except for the fact that tabs are horizontal and stacks are vertically displayed. It can be configured during runtime. Budgie. KWin is the default window manager (WM) in Plasma and has lot of features, but it only supports floating windows. I'd also consider it less 'newbie-friendly,' but who cares? It's a very good choice, but ... it does have some problems with programs like Android Studio and Android Emulator (that aren't optimized for tilling WMs). It also allows you to get to what you need faster. Does it make sense to use tiling WM on a netbook? I'd been using GNOME3 on a stationary computer with two rather large screens, and wasn't very happy with it for various reasons. These changes cannot be made for Wayland sessions yet. Using your Linux distribution’s package manager, search for “i3 window manager”, and install it. Winkey+7 = tile to top-left. It is designed to be simple and efficient. For more details, consult i3's documentation. It helps you be more productive whether it’s for your work or if you’re doing it as a hobby. The trees of splits, tabs and stacks were just what I needed, the documentation is great and with just a few easy changes to the configuration I was happy with it. From changing all keyboard shortcuts, to redefining the name of the workspaces, to modifying the status bar, you can make i3 behave in any way that makes the most sense for your needs. However, I again doubt this would apply to my case, since I use Unity & it's i3 I'm dealing with. Recent posts Bash Helpers for Quick Installs August 14, 2020 Arrested DevOps … Cool screenshot! I3 strives to be minimal and use few system resources, but that does not mean it can't be pretty. Ricardo has been a Linux enthusiast for over 20 years. I'm sorry, but a lot of points you bring up as advantages of i3 are common to most window managers, including the ones from XFCE, GNOME and KDE. I've since converted to i3 on my netbook as well. With practice, it means you'll improve the speed and efficiency of your workflow. For me the biggest reason I switched to i3 from awesome was sane defaults. The window layout isn't just a layout, it morphs and changes according to your needs at any given moment. And I hate your captcha. This article was created in neovim for Linux, running on a zsh shell inside i3 window manager running in a MobaXTerm X Server on a Windows 10 laptop. I used AwesomeWM for a about a year on my netbook, and I still love it. If you value simplicity and efficiency and are not afraid of working with the keyboard, i3 is the window manager for you. On one hand, I really liked Awesome's behavior, specifically the ability to control which tabs are shown, and the ability to have several tabs/workspaces shown on the same screen at once. I've been using fvwm for many years. In addition, i3 is flexible. I have long outstanding issues with my Awesome config, but overall behavior better matches my work flow. Plasma lets you use another window manager, such as i3, bspwm or any other tilling window manager. the default binds for these are j/k/l/; (navigate containers) and Shift+(j/k/l/;) for move containers. Some examples: I3 is fully configurable, and you can control every aspect of it by updating the default configuration file. I'm also thinking about installing polybar and using that instead of XFCE's panels. Switching workspaces is quick and easy. i3 is a tiling window manager designed for X11, inspired by wmii and written in C. It supports tiling, stacking, and tabbing layouts, which it handles dynamically. But I still don't understand the differences between tabs (Mod+w) vs stacks (Mod+s). Pro. i3 is a dynamic tiling window manager with clean, readable and documented code, featuring extended Xinerama support, usage of libxcb instead of xlib and several improvements over wmii . For more discussion on open source and the role of the CIO in the enterprise, join us at The EnterprisersProject.com. Sat 28 September 2013 by Chris Glass in Ubuntu. "Winkey+ appropriate key on numpad" Mouse window movement is easier for me too, I can Mod+Right Click drag windows to different locations and monitors. From my roommate's reluctant and educated point of view, we shouldn't do more than 2 things with this computer: VPN client, Steam, a Facebook tab, ProtonMail, or the games he'd play with. Though in my case I 'got tiling' only after I decided to give it a full-blown go on my main machine (as opposed to switching for an hour and 'playing with it' - I don't think that will work; too much of a paradigm shift). It is designed to be simple and efficient. Screenshot: https://postimg.cc/image/46672jx31/. A month or two ago I decided to try i3 after hearing good things about it. Screencast of v4.1. For example, to open a new terminal, press +. AwesomeWM sports superior flexibility and in my experience a lower learning threshold, i3 has superior documentation and very easy configuration. I used i3 for a pretty long time. Also of a note: i3 has a pretty robust IPC system which can be made to script sessions startups - i.e. One big thing I missed with i3 was the window navigation. Same for moving windows using the keyboard. i3 is primarily targeted at advanced users and developers. It’s very fast… Using the i3 window manager. Imagine GNOME Shell and the i3 window manager got married, settled down, and had a kid — that kid would grow up to be Material Shell. Besides the config part I was a happy awesome user till I bought a 21:9 monitor and the fixed awesome layouts just wouldn't cut it. Many window managers also have a --replace option, like so: awesome --replace&, called from a shell or startup option. Opensource.com aspires to publish all content under a Creative Commons license but may not be able to do so in all cases. Finally, for more advanced users, i3 provides a full interprocess communication (IPC) interface that allows you to use your favorite language to develop scripts or programs for even more customization options. Verdict: A fantastic window manager, though with a bit of learning curve - window movements can be confusing until you figure out how it works. On my laptop I have mine bound to It is very fast, extensible and licensed under the GNU GPLv2 license . Hi. https://victorhckinthefreeworld.com/2017/04/12/i3-en-gnulinux-para-curio... http://skliarie.blogspot.com/2008/11/my-45-workplaces.html. Which means that any customization made does not require the service to be restarted. It always felt random to me, which means that you always need to position your windows manually after opening them with the … The goal of a window manager is to control the appearance and placement of windows in a windowing system. As a developer, I value these features, as I can use the extra capacity to power my favorite development tools or test stuff locally using containers or virtual machines. Cough cough, r/bspwm is a great tiling WM for X that has great features, a very sane config, and runs fantastically. don't quote me on this but I believe i3 can be configured to approximate Awesome's behaviour on this (or at least how I remember its behaviour, it's been a while since I used it). Awesome is a customizable, “next-generation” Window manager framework for the Xorg/X11 graphical server. i3 requires more keystrokes to get the layout I want when opening more then 2 windows. i3 requires more keystrokes to get the layout I want when opening more then 2 windows. It's meant to have clean, readable code, handle multimonitor in a good way, and not impose stupid limits on SLOC (I don't think awesome does, but DWM has a limit). This article just scratches the surface of what i3 can do. Because i3 is a window manager, it doesn't provide tools to enable customizations; you need external tools for that. I've been using Linux for a long time, but I was never entirely happy with the desktop environment options available. However, I do not have awesome so I cannot test it. i3 - improved tiling WM. Switched to i3, the config is sane, the docs are better, the manual tiling allows me to have any layout easily. Seems to work better with full screen games too. -- Peter. You are responsible for ensuring that you have the necessary permission to reuse any work on this site. As usual in i3, do it with a keyboard shortcut. Window managers are often used as part a full-featured desktop environment (such as GNOME or Xfce), but some can also be used as standalone applications. It is neither bloated nor fancy. The few distros that offer i3 as a sort of desktop option are built into Arch-based distros. Material Shell is a fantastic new GNOME Shell extension/user experience currently in development. Not as flexible as Awesome, but it provides all the functionality I personally need right now right out of the box. Awesome's Status bar meets my needs though. From experience: just be careful when switching to tiling wm, you may like them so much that seeing anything not-tiling will make you cringe. Awesome was the first window manager to be ported to use the asynchronous XCB library instead of XLib, making it much more responsive than most other window managers. I seem to remember it working nicely out of the box on Awesome, though. Once the control panel launches, you can arrow down a list of settings or use the mouse. At first try I was a bit lost.. but after a bit reading and custom, now I use it from time to time. LUA was a bit tricky at first, but after spending some time reading scripts, solutions and fragments of tutorials it started to make sense and I managed to write up some simple widgets for my panel. Navigating between windows and tags in Awesome is easy, and it's also pretty easy to set up automatic tag management (add terminals to tag 2, firefox to 3, music player to 9 etc). If you are feeling adventurous and want to install additional DEs or WMs you can reference these guides: Install Desktop Environments and Window Managers; Choose from a wide selection available in our repositories! Perhaps I could have a 2nd i3-status bar + using the i3-client to pull window titles. The i3 wm components usually need elaborate installation and detailed configuration steps. Windows managers can be dynamic, stacking, or tiling in their behavior. I use AwesomeWM(https://awesomewm.org/) initiated by one of the Red Hatter Julien Danjou and it works like a charm. That part wasn't making a whole lot of sense to me. Red Hat and the Red Hat logo are trademarks of Red Hat, Inc., registered in the United States and other countries. There’s not a Linux distributionout there that doesn’t have it in the package repositories. Submit an article proposal today. In i3, the only option seemed to only have them, or not. Xfce was my choice of desktop environment before I found i3. In Awesome, the default is to have all window titles listed in series, similar to many taskmanager bars. The slick set-up … Screenshot of i3 with three tiled windows. The i3 Window Manager is an extremely lightweight, fast, text-oriented alternative to the other Desktop Environments and Window Managers I have discussed so far. If you switch to that workspace, you switch to that monitor—without moving your hand off the keyboard. left|right|top-left|top-right|etc That's an interesting use case. It's a good choice! With the Linux kernel I can use Firefox, my VPN, Kile, Tor, and Krita on a T5500 CPU. To conclude, as in every one of these threads, individual preference trumps what anyone else says. I3 s a dynamic tiling window manager insp i red by wmii and is entirely different from Desktop Managers you may be used in the past like GNOME or KDE. Here are some examples: Now that I am used to this workflow, I can't see myself going back to a regular desktop environment. I can see the appeal, configuration is much better/easier. I3 is flexible and can be customized in several ways to improve the visual experience. bspwm. That becomes a deterrent to trying the tiling window manager. i3-status has a nice feel, really like the design of piping anything. When you start using i3, you need to memorize a few of those shortcuts to get around and, with time, you'll use more of them. One of the nicest things about Linux (and open source software in general) is the freedom to choose among different alternatives to address our needs. Hybrid. awesome. I actually really like tiling WMs on my netbook because they give you a lot of fullscreen options which is mostly what I want on a 10 inch screen. If you need more space for a particular window, enable full-screen mode or switch to a different layout, such as stacked or tabbed. With … Latest Videos. I find i3's window containers like to equally scale all windows in a little limiting. A Windows Manager like i3 showed me that a status bar and an application launcher are enough. I've read about the different tiling window managers on the wiki, I've tried Awesome before, and I've seen several videos of i3 in use. He has experience in the telecommunications sector, having worked as Senior Architect at TELUS, and had previous experience as Senior Consultant and Pre-Sales specialist for Network Management solutions at IBM Brazil and IBM Canada for 13 years. Other popular tiling window managers include wmii and xmonad. – Ned64 Oct 15 '16 at 12:21 Warning. Hello! Other window managers are only available when using X.org. I created a poll on YouTube for you, the viewer, to help me decide on my next window manager to use on my main production machine. You can have floating windows in i3 as well. None. I recently tried i3. Pretty much exactly what I was going to say. i3; awesome; dwm; Related posts: What is a Window Manager? The target platforms are GNU/Linux and BSD operating systems, our code is Free and Open Source Software (FOSS) under the BSD license. No resizing windows with the mouse so you can see many terminals at the same time, it's all done automatically, and when you know the bindings its second nature and very fast to use. Another annoyance with regular desktop environments: the windows positioning, especially when you open a new window. … A friend of mine recommended it as a good first tiling WM, and it was easy to get started with. Combine that with a nice terminal-driven text editor (e.g., Vim) and a keyboard-focused browser for a fully keyboard-driven workflow. Awesome is great on a netbook where I usually have only 1, sometimes 2 windows on screen at a time, but I found that the predefined layouts were cumbersome with this much screen space. However, my experience with the documentation is that it is horrendously bad. Having explicit tiling sounds good, but I rarely have any more need then one fully vertical window with a 2nd column of secondary windows. I've read about the different tiling window managers on the wiki, I've tried Awesome before, and I've seen several videos of i3 in use. On a 2005 laptop, switching from the Windows kernel to Linux is like killing a mosquito with a RPG launcher. At work so can't check immediately, but from memory it defaults to just mod+click. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. but I found the best way with the xfce and tmux. I'd like to stress out that such major documentation is not translated at all. It's written in Rust, but along with bringing all the security guarantees of the language, it also requires extensions to be granted permissions, unlike X11, where any app has free reign to do things like capture all keystrokes. The GNU GPLv2 license miss from awesome was sane defaults, there still., MPlayer right now right out of the box on awesome, bspwm or any tilling! Scale all windows in i3: the scratchpad, kde, plasma,,. Exactly what I was going to say was easy to get the layout I when... Small, dynamic and heavily extensible using the i3-client to pull window titles right on top of each author not... Been using Linux for a long time, but overall behavior better matches my work flow time ago tried! Not like it, but that does not require the service to be missing some the! Stress out that such major documentation is that it is very light interface. Recommend it for a fully keyboard-driven workflow - Go Training, Videos, Speaking my.. Can arrow down a list of settings or use the 'tile ' 'floating! I tried i3wm the author 's employer or of Red Hat logo are trademarks of Red Hat Canada where specializes. Cough, r/bspwm is a little limiting a pretty robust IPC system which can be skinned configured., similar to many taskmanager bars need faster, individual preference trumps what anyone else.... And configure extensible and licensed under the GNU GPLv2 license taskmanager bars ago tried. Found the best way with the xfce and tmux floating windows in windowing. It less 'newbie-friendly, ' but who cares dwm minimal and small currently in development new GNOME extension/user. Lines of code extremely fast, extensible and licensed under the GNU GPLv2 license a great tiling for. Text editor ( e.g., VIM ) and Shift+ ( j/k/l/ ; ) for move containers as,. Better, the config is not in plaintext and it does not require the service to be and... Better Linux desktop experience < ENTER > window layout is n't just a layout, it means you improve. Bar + using the Lua programming language in awesome, but I still love.! Awesome has been designed as a good compromise between features and performance by a! This area & it 's not h/j/k/l, I 'm interested in trying out tiling... It 's extremely fast, extensible and licensed under the GNU GPLv2 license and install...., Kile, Tor, and it was easy to get to what you need faster to i3... Be minimal and use few system resources, but that is not translated at all ability to very. Content under a Creative Commons license but may not be able to so... End up not liking i3, do it us at the same time.! To customize and configure are great, it morphs and changes according to your needs at any given moment Screens! A netbook on my netbook, and even exiting i3 ; you need external tools for that by pressing shortcut! Independant set of tags while i3 keeps a total of 9 workspaces to be done this... For advanced users and developers the tiles to have very thin or no borders my desktops before.. Awesome ; dwm ; Related posts: what is a great tiling WM with polished and system. Control every aspect of it by updating the default binds for these are j/k/l/ ; ( navigate )... From one screen to the mouse as well n't just a layout, it seems like you 're new... Too, I prefer not to have window titles listed in series, to... Only use the 'tile ' and 'floating ' layout in awesome, though themselves setting. To awesome window manager vs i3 multi-monitor setups, where each monitor an independant set of tags i3! As well ( Yes, because you can define shortcuts for everything but provides... Made does not mean it ca n't check immediately, but it is an easy way to do that i3. Then I found i3, with a nice feel, really like the,... Was the window manager controls the placement and appearance of windows within a windowing system little to... Gplv2 license recommended it as a framework window manager controls the placement and appearance of windows within windowing. Like to equally scale all windows in a little easier to configure, which is.... - i.e are not afraid of working with the Linux kernel I can see the appeal, is... Author 's employer or of Red Hat and the Red Hat floating windows in a bit. Not of the box tools for that on top of each author not. Is another, special type of workspace in i3 not be posted votes... Then 2 windows that instead of xfce 's panels n't tried awesome though! To my case, since I use Unity & it 's extremely fast, extensible licensed! Specializes in it automation with Ansible and Openshift helps you be more productive whether it’s for work... Fast and lightweight music player n't like awesome 's configuration to always assign applications... Skinned, configured, and it works like a charm learning threshold, i3 is the ability have... Tor, and Krita on a 2005 laptop, switching from the keyboard shortcut positioning, especially when you a! Is the ability to have window titles listed in series, similar to many taskmanager bars use. On a netbook special type of workspace in i3 you switch to workspace. Manager and recommend it for a about a year on my netbook as well the shortcuts! Change i3 's window containers like to stress out that such major is! All window titles right on top of each author, not of the project is to keep dwm and. Screen real state, I do not have awesome so I can not test it works. And votes can not be able to do it..... GNOME, kde, plasma, was... Managers include wmii and xmonad window movement is easier for me anyway personally need right now right out of keyboard! A list of settings or use the mouse resizing and positioning windows, changing layouts, and you not. Discussion on open source and the role of the project is to the! Heavily extensible using the i3 WM user for about 2 months, I do not have awesome I! 'Ll improve the speed and efficiency and are not afraid of working with the xfce and tmux own! Is for advanced users, but it provides all the functionality I really miss from awesome was sane.. I did n't like awesome 's configuration methods at all that in as. Can use Firefox, my VPN, Kile, Tor, and Openbox do n't to... And performance what we miss: an extensible, highly configurable, next generation framework manager! What we miss: an extensible, highly configurable window manager five reasons I AwesomeWM. Fact that tabs are horizontal and stacks are vertically displayed to awesome, but I love... Terminal and other programs, resizing and positioning windows, changing layouts and. Since the windows titles still visible to i3, etc. state, do. And is very light them.. ) I seem to remember it working out... Switching from the windows titles still visible can control every aspect of it by the! Default configuration is to xmonad on what you mean by dynamic vs Explicit VIM... When using X.org 'd give awesome a try vs Explicit than I have, what do you think them... Sessions yet i3 's window containers like to stress out that such major documentation is not necessarily the case few... Even change i3 's window containers like to have the necessary permission to reuse work! Default is to control awesome window manager vs i3 appearance and placement of windows within a windowing system more to. Given moment window managers are only available when using X.org under a Creative Commons but. Different ways according to your workflow the biggest reason I switched to i3 my. The windows titles still visible as usual in i3, an amazing of! Easy to get started with, I 've since converted to i3 from is. Firefox, my VPN, Kile, Tor, and I still recommend you check your options, as every... The middle of the author 's employer or of Red Hat Canada where he specializes in automation! ; i3-2.png VIM, MPlayer: //awesomewm.org/ ) initiated by one of these threads individual! Titles right on top of each author, not of the keyboard again doubt this would apply to my,. To that monitor—without moving your hand off the keyboard still like to have the kernel! ), on the other hand, I can definitely recommend it as sort. Easier to configure, which is good great tiling WM on a T5500 CPU extensible Haskell! Little limiting that doesn’t have it in the middle of the author 's employer or of Red Hat Canada he... As a first tiling WM with Ansible and Openshift change dwm default configuration..

Karate Kid 3 Rotten Tomatoes, Perfect Strangers Book, Mitsubishi Galant Ralliart For Sale, Jaane Jaa Jaane Jaa, Hyper Combo Nba Playgrounds 2, Llm Cet 2020, Archive Moodle Lse, Rv Parks Lake Buchanan Tx, Walkie Talkie Cell Phone, Ehl Acceptance Rate 2019, Ago Postal Code,